The 4% Rule: Helpful Guide or Outdated Myth?

If you’ve spent any time researching retirement income strategies, you’ve probably come across the famous “4% rule.”

It’s a simple idea: withdraw 4% of your retirement savings in the first year, then adjust that amount each year for inflation. The goal is to stretch your nest egg for about 30 years.

On paper, that sounds like a neat, tidy solution. But as with most rules of thumb in retirement planning, the 4% rule has some serious limitations.

Where the 4% Rule Comes From

The 4% rule for retirement withdrawals was introduced in the mid-1990s by financial planner Bill Bengen. He studied historical stock and bond data (all the way back to the Great Depression and the 1970s inflation crisis) and concluded that retirees who stuck with a 4% withdrawal rate didn’t run out of money for at least 30 years.

The Problems With Relying on 4%

1. Everyone’s situation is different.

If you retire early or live well into your 90s, 30 years of withdrawals may not cut it. Healthcare costs, lifestyle choices, and family needs can shift dramatically as the years go on.

2. Markets don’t always cooperate.

The 4% rule assumes that markets will behave somewhat like they have in the past. But what if stocks and bonds both struggle (like we saw in 2022)? A rigid safe withdrawal rate doesn’t adapt well to unexpected conditions.

3. One splurge can throw it off.

The 4% rule assumes you’ll stick to it, year after year. But let’s be honest—life happens. A new camper, a dream vacation, helping kids or grandkids… these decisions can disrupt the math.

The Real Issue: Consistent, Predictable Income

Here’s what often gets overlooked: retirees need a reliable place to draw income, regardless of market conditions.

If all of your retirement income depends on the stock market, you could be forced to sell investments at a loss during a downturn. That’s called sequence of returns risk, and it’s one of the biggest dangers to a retirement portfolio.

The 4% rule doesn’t solve this problem—it just hopes the markets cooperate.

That’s why retirees need a strategy that blends:

• Safety: Guaranteed income sources that don’t swing with the market.

• Protection: Assets designed to grow conservatively and keep up with inflation.

• Growth: Investments that capture long-term market returns to outpace rising costs.

This “bucket strategy for retirement income” helps ensure you’re not relying solely on averages, guesses, or luck. Instead, you have structured income to pay your bills, while still giving your nest egg room to grow.

So, Does the 4% Rule Still Work?

As a starting point, it can be useful. It’s simple, predictable, and helps people think about how much they can reasonably spend in retirement.

But here’s the truth- your retirement is not an average.

You don’t live in a “hypothetical 30-year case study.” You live in Cedar Rapids (or nearby), with your own goals, your own health, and your own savings.

That means your retirement withdrawal strategy should be built around your circumstances—not a decades-old rule of thumb.

The Bottom Line

The 4% rule can be a helpful benchmark, but it’s not a retirement plan. Relying on it blindly can lead to overspending, underspending, or unnecessary stress.

A smarter approach is to create a personalized retirement income plan—one that gives you the confidence of consistent cash flow, while still leaving room for flexibility and growth.

If you’re unsure whether your retirement income plan can weather market ups and downs, let’s talk. At Iowa Retirement Benefits & Solutions, we’ll help you build a strategy that gives you reliable income—no matter what the market does.

Email us at info@iowaretirementsolutions.com
Call us at 319-423-3332
Click here to schedule your free consultation.

Investment advisory services are offered through Fusion Capital Management, an SEC registered investment advisor. The firm only transacts business in states where it is properly registered or is excluded or exempted from registration requirements. SEC registration is not an endorsement of the firm by the commission and does not mean that the advisor has attained a specific level of skill or ability. All investment strategies have the potential for profit or loss.